Schneider's Bakery
A Cooperstown Classic
With almost a century of baking mastery, Schneider's is your stop for donuts and pastries that have stood the test of time—perfect for a traditional holiday breakfast or dessert!
The Fly Creek Cider Mill
Where Pies Reach Legendary Status
Home to an iconic Caramel Apple Pie, Fly Creek’s holiday lineup includes epic Christmas pies that are available for pre-order now. Stop by for a slice of history…and cider, and crunchies, and salsa and molasses cookies!
Five Kids Bakehouse in Gilbertsville
Family-Run, Flavor-Packed
This family bakehouse serves up the kind of treats that feel homemade—because they are! Expect unique flavors and rustic charm in every sweet flaky pastry and loaf of warm crusty bread you can put your hands on.
Freestyle Confections
Confections With a Twist
Known for their inventive creations, Freestyle Confections brings fun and flair to traditional sweets including design-your-own cookie kits. Perfect for anyone who wants to add a bit of whimsy to the holiday dessert table.
The Sugar Beat
Indulgence, Elevated
The Sugar Beat in Oneonta doesn’t shy away from decadence! Their holiday offerings include dreamy cookies, pastries, and pies that are just as Instagrammable as they are delicious.
Social Eats Cafe - Project 607
The Sweet Spot for Seasonal Delights
Known for its modern vibes, Social Eats delivers on seasonal goodness with everything from custom cakes and pies to sweet treats that pair perfectly with your morning coffee (or a getaway spot just to be on your own.)
The Cooperstown Farmers Market
Your Holiday Foodie Wonderland
With vendors like Chloe's Bake Shop, Cooperstown Maple Works, and Laura’s Chocolates, this market has both baked goods and farm-fresh ingredients for every part of your holiday spread.
