Slice, slice baby.

The dish on where to get the best pizza in the Cooperstown area.

We recommend consulting each business before visiting, as many of them operate seasonally and have varying hours of operation as well as alterations due to COVID-19 guidelines.

“Anyone who says that money cannot buy happiness has clearly never spent their money on pizza.” – Andrew W.K.

There’s no wonder why America’s favorite food is pizza. A heavenly slice of homemade dough layered with sweet red marinara sauce and gooey cheese, is the perfect food for most occasions. Pizza shops in and around Cooperstown are no exception to the classic pie. Local chefs have spent years perfecting their rich recipes and ingredients to offer you the best.

• Tino’s Pizza: 180 Main St., Oneonta
  • Home of the “cold cheese slice”, a slice of hot cheese pizza topped with a handful of cold, shredded mozzarella. It was invented to keep hungry folks from burning the roof of their mouths with slices fresh out of the oven!
  • Limited indoor and outdoor seating.
• Oneonta Sal’s Pizza: 285 S Main St., Oneonta
  • Oneonta’s go-to shop for pizza, tangy subs and tasty garlic knots. Make sure you try their own recipe for cold cheese pizza.
  • Limited indoor and outdoor seating.
• Cooperstown Sal’s Pizza: 110 Main St., Cooperstown
  • Quick and delicious pizza for those on the go in downtown Cooperstown.
  • Indoor seating and large parties welcome outback.
• Bocca Osteria: 5438 NY-28, Cooperstown
  • Authentic Neapolitan pizzas perfected in a custom-made oven from Naples, Italy
  • Limited indoor and tented outdoor seating, private events welcome and optional catering, call ahead.
• New York Pizzeria - Cooperstown: 75 Chestnut St., Cooperstown
  • New-York styled pizza with big city flavors in a picturesque small town.
  • Limited indoor and seasonal outdoor seating with optional catering.
• Maskots: 4551 NY-28, Cooperstown
  • A fun environment for all the players, coaches and spectators. Located across the road from Cooperstown Dream Park.
  • Large seating area for parties with a reservation 3 hours or more prior to event.
• The Pizza Genie: 2805 St Hwy 80, Burlington Flats, NY 13315 typically found at  High Burl Brewery and Rustic Ridge Winery
  • A pizza truck with original wood fired pizza.
  • Outdoor picnic tables at the brewery and winery for seating.
• Pizza 23 West: 3915 NY-23, West Oneonta
  • The best place around for a Grandma slice!
  • Limited indoor seating.
• Pizzaland: 24 Oneida St., Cooperstown
  • Tasty authentic Italian food!
  • Has enough seating to accommodate large groups, but please call for details.
• Spike’s Pizza and Grocery: 5 East Street, Edmeston
  • On the go, one-stop shop for party platters, meaty subs and classic pizza.
  • Small seating area indoors and outdoors.