Add to Trip Planner

Old Gristmill Antiques & Collectibles

Our dealers are committed to offering you a variety of quality antiques, vintage collectibles, and furniture at reasonable prices.

Our historic 4,000 square foot Gristmill is located along the Susquehanna River, at the mouth of Goodyear Lake, just south of Cooperstown on State Highway 28 and only 8 miles from Oneonta, New York. Use Exit 17 off I-88 to State Highway 28 North.

COVID19 Update

Please check for details on the business’ website for the most up-to-date information on possible limited hours, max capacities, whether reservations are necessary or not, etc.  NY Tough and united with ALL, Cooperstown is keeping everyone’s health & safety front and centerClick HERE for more specific guidelines for traveling within New York State, including a Travel Advisory issued June 25th requiring a 14-day quarantine for inbound travelers from certain states. 

General Information

  • 28378 State Highway 28, Portlandville, NY, 13834

  • Directions
  • (607) 441-3152

Season / Hours of Operation

Summer Hours: Memorial Day - Labor Day open 7 days a week, Monday – Saturday 10 – 5 Sunday Noon – 5. We are Closed the Months of January & February for Winter Hibernation.


    Explore Cooperstown, NY

    Known as baseball’s birthplace, but home to so much more, Cooperstown is a place where legends roam hallowed halls, swing away on diamonds, and take to the stage under a canopy of stars. The historic village boasts a vibrant arts scene, excellent local food and beverage options, luxury accommodations, and, of course, more baseball than you can shake a bat at.

    Start Exploring
    Recite Me Accessibility Button